As MLK Memorial Being Built, the Legacy of Harriet Tubman is In Question

harriet tubman's legacy is in question

by Carolyn Evans-Dean

As the nation prepares to gather in Washington DC for the official unveiling of the memorial to Dr. Martin Luther King, a controversy is brewing over how to commemorate the life of another beloved African American figure. The State of Maryland recently revealed plans to create a $21 million park in Cambridge to honor the life and legacy of Harriet Tubman. A state park would seem to be an appropriate way to commemorate her life and yet, there is growing disagreement as to the location and the amount of funding that the project has received.

Tubman, best known for leading countless black slaves out of bondage to the freedom that was to be found in the northern states and Canada, was often referred to as ‘the Moses of her people.’ Among her lesser known accomplishments were her successes as a Union Army spy and her philanthropic endeavors to create a home for aged and indigent former slaves in Auburn, NY.

.While Harriet Tubman was born on a farm in Dorchester County Maryland, she eventually escaped bondage in 1849 and made her way to the north. Over the years she returned repeatedly to Maryland bringing out family members and many others, earning the nickname of “Moses”.

There are few historical artifacts and no structures remaining from Tubman’s life in the state of Maryland. Likely due to the fact that slaves weren’t allowed much in the way of possessions or property. The memorial park would seek to bring these places back to life by creating a trail for future generations to follow, keeping the Tubman legacy alive. This idea greatly pleases Valerie Manokey of Cambridge MD. The 75 year old is one of Harriet Tubman’s descendents and was quoted as saying, ‘It is awesome. It’s like something inside you that was growing and you knew someone would see the significance and it would blossom and now you see the buds on the tree. I pray that I’ll be here to see it.’ But what of Harriet Tubman’s life in New York?

Five hundred miles away in the quiet city of Auburn NY, Tubman House and Home sits on land that is steeped in history. The Central New York area had long been a hotbed of the anti-slavery movement. Harriet Tubman purchased her home and land from William Seward. At that time, he was a former State Senator and Governor of New York. As Secretary of State under Abraham Lincoln, Seward later gained fame for the purchase of the vast expanse of land that is now known as Alaska. This purchase increased the size of the United States by approximately one-third.

It was Auburn that Tubman called home during the last fifty years of her life and she settled her aged parents and other family members there. In 1903, she signed her property over to the care of the African Methodist Episcopal Church, where it has remained for more than one hundred years. Upon her death in 1913, she was eulogized in the Thompson African Methodist Episcopal Church and buried in the Fort Hill Cemetery, both of which are located in Auburn. One year after her death, the city of Auburn placed a memorial tablet at the Cayuga County Courthouse to honor the Tubman legacy.

The Tubman House and Home is a museum that receives little federal funding. According to New York State Senator Chuck Schumer, the site received only $11,750 in 2004. That pales in comparison to the $8.5 million that the Maryland project is slated to receive from the Federal Transportation Enhancement Program, and the disparity has rankled some folks in New York. Many feel that it is unfair to overlook a site that has so much actual Tubman lore and infrastructure in favor of creating a new site with modern or replica structures to honor one of America’s best known historical figures.

Over the years, many politicians and dignitaries have visited the Tubman House and Home to learn about the legacy of a woman called Moses. The project in Maryland has some people in New York wondering if their connection and familial relationships  to Harriet Tubman will be overshadowed by a big budget project, located in a state where plantation owners once offered a reward of $40,000 for the capture of America’s most famous conductor of the Underground Railroad.

Published in: on August 25, 2011 at 3:19 pm  Comments (11)  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

11 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. […] (more…) Like this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

  2. […] (more…) Filed Under: Uncategorized […]

  3. […] (more…) Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

  4. Well, I would hope that it’s not an either/or type situation. This icon and beacon of justice should be honored the world-over, both in Auburn and Maryland. We must stress to our young people the importance of people like Dr. King and Harriet Tubman, so that they’ll be inclined to become stewards of our people’s struggling and fighting legacy. It’s important that Black people lead the way these heroes and heroines are enshrined on monuments and in museums. I’m glad Dr. King’s being honored in Washington, but I’m also disturbed by the whitewashed version of him that people are being presented. Unfortunately, when corporate money becomes involved, those interests tend to dictate the way they want our heroes to be “remembered.” That must stop.

  5. How lovely…How lovely…I feel very very overwhelmed right now…Dear God, it is about time something special is going to be done to honor this woman’s legacy…..

  6. The ‘only’ way this sort of nonsense is to stop is if ‘African Americans’ take the initial steps in the process. How do WE do this? How do WE start to target and use OUR OWN funding to get the jobs done? What are WE going to do???, so that ‘NO-ONE’ would have to…or be able to ‘TELL’ “US” what to do?? WE CAN DO IT!!! Let’s get started!!! Mother Tubman earned it!!

  7. I totally agree…please, never forget Lady Harriet Tubman.

  8. She’s one of the earlier inductees to that Celestial Pantheon of Female Warriors. Oh what a legacy “Lady Harriet Tubman” left us.

  9. I think the proposals of both NY and Maryland are worthy of honoring this wonderful icon of African American history. PLEASE, PLEASE, lets not get into the “my place” not “your place” bickering for God’s sake! Lets just GET IT DONE!

  10. No question this is great! Let’s build community foundations all over America and we won’t need others to honor us.

  11. I agree with many of the commens. Just this week my husband and was watching how a football players was holding out to earn millions of dollars. He got the millions now, even with out a thought, we have to fight for honor of our past to give pride to our future as women. We have to fight for what is right for in history. I don’t know but can money be raised the same way that President Obama did, can history be honored the same way, Penny by Penny, Step by Step, We can do it,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: